General Motors braking hard on Facebook ads

Yesterday’s post was comparing the efficiency of Facebook vs. Google ads and already today there are news that confirm the theory, judging on the new business move done by General Motors.

They are moving away from the Facebook ads due its low consumer impact. They are not totally moving out as they will keep the fan pages online and cut on advertising spend. Available numbers say that $40 million was spent on the advertising, but only $10 million has actually been paid to this social network for ads.

“We regularly review our overall media spend and make adjustments as needed. This happens as a regular course of business and it’s not unusual for us to move our spending around various media outlets, especially with the growth of multiple social and digital media outlets,” says GM in a statement. “In terms of Facebook specifically, we are reassessing our advertising, but we remain committed to an aggressive content strategy through all of our products and brands, as it continues to be a very effective tool for engaging with our customers.”

General Motors is among the top 5 advertisers in the United States, settling in the 3rd place spending and estimate of $1.1 billion on US ads in 2011 as presented by Kantar Media. Out of that budget, online advertising has significant part of $271 million, split between two categories of display and search ads, and excluding Facebook ads.

A recent AP-CNBC poll showed that eight in 10 Facebook users in the US say they hardly ever (26%) or never (57%) click on online advertising or sponsored content when using the site.

 

Internet ad performance – Google is much better choice than Facebook?

Being present frequently at the marketing and communication strategy meetings, you can hear a line “Why don’t you use a part of the media mix budget and advertise on the internet? Facebook is the good choice”.

Is that so? Well, no one actually got into trouble for suggesting this kind of channel, but the situation just might change if  the decision makers read this article.

So, the question is, whether Facebook is an efficient and cost-effective vehicle for marketeres and communication and social media gurus or there is a better performance-wise offer waiting for you on the “other” side?

Let us look into the comparison of Facebook and Google conducted by the WordStream, a search marketing management company. They suggest that Google is more effective than Facebook. (Remark here is that Wordstream might be more close to the Google so as always we take this analysis with a pinch of salt)

According to Wordstream numbers (click here for the full infographic): Facebook has less reach, and its individual ads are less effective compared to old-fashioned web advertising.

The most worrying data for Facebook is the average click-through rate for the internet ad that is generally just 0.1 percent.

At Facebook, it is even lower, just 0.051 percent while Google’s rate is at 0.4 percent.

Here is the summary of the research:

TOTAL REACH

Facebook > 51% of all internet users

Google > 90% of all internet users

2012 Q1 REVENUES

Facebook > $1.06 billion, meaning it is down 6.5 percent year on year and big 32% sequentially

Google > $2.9 billion, up by 1 percent year on year, while it is up by 0.7% sequentially

CLICK-THROUG RATES

Facebook > 0.051 percent

Google > 0.4 percent

Average CTR > 0.1 percent

TARGETING

Facebook > Education, Workplace, Likes, Location, Demographics

Google > Interest, Keywords, Remarketing, Location, Demographics

FORMATS

Facebook > standard display ad, sponsored stories

Google > text ads, image ads, video text overlay ads, mobile web game ads

So what can we expect in the future, will CEO of Facebook Mark Zuckerberg focus on developing further the advertising platform and keep up with Google or he considers some other source of revenue?

If we judge the 2500+ word letter to his shareholders, as mentioned by Larry Kim from WordStream, where he mentioned advertising just once, he just might focus on something else.

Facebook Timeline, changes compared to old brand pages?

Starting from March 30th, Facebook Timeline type of view will be applied to all of the pages, personal and business automatically. The infographic below is showing what is changing and how it will look like.

If you just want to re-design your personal profile or you are into something more serious with a business or a brand page, go through it, print it out and be sure to tighten everything before the automatic switch.

[click on the photo so you can zoom in]

Here are some of the explanations of the above infographic.

[2] Facebook marketers are familiar with the tactic of directing fans to default landing tabs before accessing a brand page. It will not be possible by default, though, individual app tabs can be linked through ads or updates on Facebook, and new “Pinned Posts” can serve as mini landing tabs that can last up to one week each. App space now provides room for up to 810 pixels for your content!

[3] The biggest change is definitely the big, spacious cover photo that now sits atop brand pages. This enables brands to demonstrate their latest branding and visually stunning images. The cover photo is 851×315 pixels in area.

[4] Apps and views are now just below the profile picture and cover photo, centred across the middle of the page. Facebook allows pages to specify up to 11 custom app tabs to populate the space, next to the default “Photos” tab for the pages latest photos (making it 12 app tabs in total).

[5] Fans can now also send personal messages to the administrators for all of the suggestions and other comments. This message center is now located above the Facebook page timeline, and updates dynamically to alert page admins of new messages from fans.

[6] The “About” section of the page now rests directly below the profile picture and is meant to be used for brand or company info. Facebook supports 3 lines of content here, so a one or two sentence description is recommended.

[7] Page names can be changed now. Just go to the admin panel and “Help” to enter your request for a page name change.

[8] Pages with timeline can now post a variety of updates, rather than the traditional status update of the past. Timeline pages can share posts, photos, links, videos, questions and milestones. Milestones are considered “Big” posts that automatically expand to fill the width of the timeline, while any of the updates can be expanded or “Pinned” as well to show significance! January 1, 1800 is the earliest a post can be dated, for those companies looking to expand on their expansive history.

[9] Friend activity is no longer relegated to a small link on the left. With timeline, activity from friend’s interacting with a brand page automatically shows up in a small box at the top of the timeline for you to see.

[10] Facebook “Insights” is now combined into the “Admin Panel” which displays new “Notifications, Likes, Insights, Messages and Page Tips”. Clicking on any attribute within the Admin Panel will take users into a more detailed section to interact.

For everyone dealing with social media, creatively or in any other way should be acquainted with the above mentioned and using it.

Remember, March 30th is the deadline!

Infographic source: Visual.ly user: thumyeemun

Another candy, 2012 Trend Report by JWT Intelligence

After the Cultural Fuel by Leo Burnett here is another candy for everyone that likes to look ahead and implement the newest trends in their own thinking, ideas, campaigns and winnings.

Here are 100 things to watch in 2012 compiled by the JWT Intelligence.

Enjoy and take notes!

Also, leave a comment if you like it, if you agree or disagree.

 

Cultural fuel trend report February 2012 by Leo Burnett

I don’t know if you have used-up all the ideas, opinions, insights and inspiration from the January trend report by Leo Burnett, but here is another volume for February.

Get your drinks, relax and enjoy the presentation, there might be a powerful insight for your next Cannes Grand Prix campaign.

 

Beware of Vip Mobile Services in Serbia, cash mercenaries lurking around?

I was thinking if I should write a post about this and finally decided to actually do it. At the first instance, I wanted just to complain and then decided to analyse it business and communication wise.

To put it briefly, Vip Mobile Serbia part of Mobilkom Austria network is “selling” its debts to the “debt hunting” companies. Nothing would be especially strange in this story that my debt was not 2.000 RSD (below 20 EUR) and that I was not one month late with the payments.

The similar thing already happened couple of months before, I was contacted by the “debt hunting” agency and a rude operator communicated with me aggressively, and the debt was in the similar amount (below 20 EUR). After sending an e-mail explaining this situation I got no response from the company, and it happened again.

The reason behind this post is not complaining, but a critique of the communication style of Vip Mobile, done professionally.

So, the service I signed-up for is the mobile internet, the monthly fee for these services is 1.000 RSD (below 10 EUR) which is around 120 EUR per year. Soon as I signed up for the service I recommended it to a lot of my friends as a value for money way to surf the internet on the go. As a result, I know for sure that 15 of my friends signed-up for the same service, some even took a more expensive service (around 16 EUR, yearly around 190 EUR). Probably some of their friends also signed-up for the service due to their recommendation, and let’s say that at least 5 of their friends signed-up.

To better explain this I have made the graph below depicting the amount of people and the revenue coming from them, by taking the mid-level package (10 EUR) and calculating on the yearly level.

This represents at least around 11.000 EUR revenue per year, excluding more expensive package, excluding additional services that these people might be using. Now, going back to me being disappointed about the service, meaning that I will cancel the service and for a certain period of time, no matter how good the actual service could be, won’t be using Vip Mobile services. Aditionaly, I will communicate this to my friends, telling them about my experience which can result in more service cancelling. They will talk to their friends and you will see the power of butterfly effect.

If we take that not all of the connected friends will cancel the service, but rather 30% of them, this means at least around 3.000 EUR less revenue per year. You would argue that this does not mean much to the big Telco company, but, if you look at the amount of money  that they are “lacking” due to my late payments (20 EUR for two months, remember?) it is not hard to conclude that they are losing revenue (my own, and from other people cancelling or switching service), loyal consumers and damaging their image.

So, what is the fix?

First, classification of the customers by their debt, if someone is owing the company serious amounts or is late more than 6 months then the problem should be transferred to the “debt hunting” companies because you have a firm reason to do so. Also, they must think about the potential of the customers, as for example I was considering some expensive packages as I can afford it, so I am a high potential customer.

Secondly, pay attention to customers’ e-mails, complaints, suggestions, because not all of them are crazy and boring.

Lastly, in the high competitive market (7 million people, 3 mobile telephony companies) you just cannot lose customers because of ridiculous reasons.

To conclude, a company like Vip Mobile Serbia, that has one of the best customer services must pay attention to this kind of mistakes.

Disclaimer: This article is written based on the personal experience of the author. All the amounts and calculations used in the business overview are used only as a fiction to depict the subject of the text.

Google is down?

There have been problems with Google search this morning and it continues still. The same problem has been reported from various countries of the world so there must be a huge problem with the service.

If you have experienced these problems please leave a comment.

Also, I have found an URL that gives the feedback whether the Google.com is down, logically the site address is: http://www.isgoogledown.com/

iPad 3 to be launched on March 7th?

After significant number of rumours, “reviews” and even design proposals by independent artists, the date for the probable iPad 3 launch event has been set. March 7th is the date when we might see, hear and touch (at least the lucky one’s attending the event) the new Apple tablet.

The invitation (see above) does not directly imply that it will be the launch of iPad 3 but the tech public is assured that this will happen.

Going back to the features of the new iPad 3, majority of experts are expecting that it will contain couple of new tech innovations in a package similar to the 2nd generation device.

The new Apple gadget will be just 1mm thicker compared to the previous iPad, but the majority of the front panel will be taken by the new 9.7 inch Retina Display. Increased storage is also expected together with the camera that should be improved.

If you have an opinion what else might show up with the launch iPad 3 please drop a couple of lines below?

Watch out for your accumulated Google history, 2 more days to fix this!

For all of you that are following the digital and social media industry this is probably just a reminder, but for everyone else not so “techie oriented” here is just a last minute reminder, before it is too late.

You probably noticed in the last month or so, that on google.com and gmail.com and other Google services there is a small button where you can read about their new policy that starts from March the 1st.

What this actually means is that it allows Google to gather, store and use personal information for their own purposes.

So, are you ready to fix this right away, or you want to read more?

If you do not fix this you can expect that once this policy is activated all data that is already collected about you (searches, visited sites, age, gender, location) will be assigned to your online identity that will be visible through your Gmail and YouTube Accounts.

According to Daily Mail, deleting your browsing history before March 1 when Google’s new privacy policy comes into effect will limit Google’s ability to track and record your every move online.

Are you willing to fix this? Here are the instructions:

  1. Go to Google homepage and sign into your account
  2. Click the dropdown menu next to your name in the upper-right corner of your screen
  3. Click accounts settings
  4. Find the “Services sections”
  5. Under “Services “there is a sub-section that reads “View, enable, disable web history. “Click the link next to it that reads: “Go to web history.”
  6. Click on “Remove all Web History”

When you click this, a message appears that says “Web history is paused. “What this means is that Google will continue gathering and storing information about your web history and it will make all data anonymous, and not associating your Web History information with your online accounts and will therefore be unable to send you customized search results.

Google’s ability to gather personalized information about you by assigning data to your Gmail and YouTube accounts will remain “Paused “until you click “Resume”.